MATCHWATCH : Burton Albion (a)

[Stranded]

On the one hand the football we are playing is absolutely dire and there is no way we even deserved a point tonight. On the other hand you have to give credit to the players for keeping on getting results.

How we are 6th is beyond me. I guess most of our competitors are just as awful.

It's not that they are any better or worse than us, it's just that we have found a really good knack of picking up wins/draws even when the performance is not much cop by focusing on the high percentage moments. Other teams have perhaps not been quite as good at doing that as us. The only thing that may cost us the play-offs now is that start where we only picked up 5 pts in the first 7 games - even 1 more win in that run and we'd be looking pretty comfortable right now.

I’ll accept we got a couple of big decisions go our way, but If they can’t score a 1 on 1, and finish off other half decent chances then that’s not luck.

I didn’t think we were awful tbh - some periods we were pretty bad but others pretty good. It wasn’t Mansfield part 2

Stats wise it was reasonably even, not like we didn’t have other shots and opportunities ourselves

Even without playing well we have the quality to win games in goal and in the front 4. Sometimes that’s all you need

Yeah, I wasn't really referring to last night more a general season vibe but yes, if you have a strong (for the level) front 4, you will likely end up nearer the top than the bottom.

[RoyalBlue]

JP made some big saves last night, whereas the Burton keeper gifted us a win. I don't think his moment was a red, there were covering defenders.

Yep, freekick possibly but never a red. Interestingly, I saw a post on Twitter from a Burton fan showing the incident and he merely stated that they should've had a free-kick in the first thirty seconds, no call for a card at all.

[hobnob]

test

[tidus_mi2]

JP made some big saves last night, whereas the Burton keeper gifted us a win. I don't think his moment was a red, there were covering defenders.

Yep, freekick possibly but never a red. Interestingly, I saw a post on Twitter from a Burton fan showing the incident and he merely stated that they should've had a free-kick in the first thirty seconds, no call for a card at all.

I saw it as well and a lot was made of how JP handled the ball out the area but it was clearly accidental, you could argue he fouled the Burton player but I think we had players covering, not very clear from the video though.

[South Coast Royal]

JP made some big saves last night, whereas the Burton keeper gifted us a win. I don't think his moment was a red, there were covering defenders.

He's definitely got more erratic this season and I expect we'll look for proper competition in the summer so he's not a guaranteed starter. But he's still an excellent shot stopper and made a big difference last night.

You only had to look at the 2 goalkeepers last night and on Saturday to appreciate how good Joel is at this level.

The Plymouth keeper went missing for both goals and last night we would have been livid if our keeper had failed to punch the ball away letting Kelvin score his header-a keeper has such an advantage in those circumstances.

Coupled with the saves that Joel made the net result of the performances of the 3 goalkeepers is that just over these 2 games we are 2 or 3 points better off than we might have been.

As for the no penalty from Yiadom it was a blatant push in the back and he didn't get the ball.

The gods are still with us folks.

[LUX]

Yes, general view now is that the handball was not intentional, JP was looking the other way and his arms were in a natural position having fallen, plus there were covering defenders. They certainly should have had a free kick, though.

OTOH they reckon they should have had a surefire penalty ( Yiadom foul?).

[Snowflake Royal]

Just typed out a detailed take on both handball and penalty and it’s vanished into a void, so a shorter summary.

Great officiating in both cases.

Never a handball offence, neither deliberate play of the ball with hand, nor any making himself bigger to gain advangate. Two officials with clear as day views.

Penalty, wouldn’t blame the ref for giving it. It's very physical, highly risky and hard to see well from behind, but Yids does get his body infront and wrap his foot around the ball to take it. No pen.

[windermereROYAL]

Just typed out a detailed take on both handball and penalty and it’s vanished into a void, so a shorter summary.

Great officiating in both cases.

Never a handball offence, neither deliberate play of the ball with hand, nor any making himself bigger to gain advangate. Two officials with clear as day views.

Penalty, wouldn’t blame the ref for giving it. It's very physical, highly risky and hard to see well from behind, but Yids does get his body infront and wrap his foot around the ball to take it. No pen.

That`s the way I saw both of them too.

[Armadillo Roadkill]

Just typed out a detailed take on both handball and penalty and it’s vanished into a void, so a shorter summary.

Great officiating in both cases.

Never a handball offence, neither deliberate play of the ball with hand, nor any making himself bigger to gain advangate. Two officials with clear as day views.

Penalty, wouldn’t blame the ref for giving it. It's very physical, highly risky and hard to see well from behind, but Yids does get his body infront and wrap his foot around the ball to take it. No pen.

That`s the way I saw both of them too.

With the greatest of respect, I could hardly disagree more.

Joel knows exactly what he's doing with his trailing arm. Should have been a yellow though, not a red, as there was a covering defender. Could have given a red though without too much of a stretch of the imagination.

Yids doesn't not in any way get the ball until he has clattered the Burton defender. Clear penalty.

Over the course of the season I'm sure Burton will have had a few favourable decisions, and we've certainly had a few go against us. But last night we got lucky.

[Snowflake Royal]

Just typed out a detailed take on both handball and penalty and it’s vanished into a void, so a shorter summary.

Great officiating in both cases.

Never a handball offence, neither deliberate play of the ball with hand, nor any making himself bigger to gain advangate. Two officials with clear as day views.

Penalty, wouldn’t blame the ref for giving it. It's very physical, highly risky and hard to see well from behind, but Yids does get his body infront and wrap his foot around the ball to take it. No pen.

That`s the way I saw both of them too.

With the greatest of respect, I could hardly disagree more.

Joel knows exactly what he's doing with his trailing arm. Should have been a yellow though, not a red, as there was a covering defender. Could have given a red though without too much of a stretch of the imagination.

Yids doesn't not in any way get the ball until he has clattered the Burton defender. Clear penalty.

Over the course of the season I'm sure Burton will have had a few favourable decisions, and we've certainly had a few go against us. But last night we got lucky.

I think these things are often open to some interpretation and discussion. But when it comesto any decision the trained and highly experienced officials have a good view of and have made a concrete and emphatic decision on rather than potentially been unsighted or just straight up missed, you're on a hiding to nothing.

We all give refs huge stick, but they're far better at knowing the laws, interpreting the laws and making the calls than any of us.

[Snowflake Royal]

Also you can tell by Pereira's reaction its not deliberate. He practically shits himself and does everything he can to avoid the ball with his arm as he's getting up.

[Sutekh]

That`s the way I saw both of them too.

With the greatest of respect, I could hardly disagree more.

Joel knows exactly what he's doing with his trailing arm. Should have been a yellow though, not a red, as there was a covering defender. Could have given a red though without too much of a stretch of the imagination.

Yids doesn't not in any way get the ball until he has clattered the Burton defender. Clear penalty.

Over the course of the season I'm sure Burton will have had a few favourable decisions, and we've certainly had a few go against us. But last night we got lucky.

I think these things are often open to some interpretation and discussion. But when it comesto any decision the trained and highly experienced officials have a good view of and have made a concrete and emphatic decision on rather than potentially been unsighted or just straight up missed, you're on a hiding to nothing.

We all give refs huge stick, but they're far better at knowing the laws, interpreting the laws and making the calls than any of us.

Except those on VAR of course

[Hound]

I did think JP did make himself a bit bigger with his arm, but then the actual contact was accidental. Prob a Fk and a yellow imo.

Yids I thought the same though only saw it a couple of times, their striker should have shot first time and yids then got his body between the player and the ball and came away with it. Wouldn’t be suprised if there was another angle to prove me wrong though, first impression was a pen

[Clyde1998]

Certainly think we were lucky to come away with the win last night (yet again). Think we would've definitely lost had their #10 scored the one-on-one with Pereira just before Doyle's goal.

Pereira certainly should've been booked for handball in the first few minutes; was right in front on me and the knew what he was doing. Can't remember the Yiadom penalty incident off the top of my head, tbh. Great to see Ehibhatiomhan get another goal.

Can't quite understand how we've ended up in the play-off spots which how we've been playing, but the results have been there regardless. Saturday is a massive game us.

Also, I've come back to the site changing.